Legal and charter

Article II — The Fourth Law of Logic

The philosophy that would guide the Board's judgment, and the limits on it.

Approved by the Board for implementation · 20 November 2026

Approved

Approved by the Board for implementation, 20 November 2026. Counsel is confirming the open points, shown in [brackets]. These bylaws work under Delaware law and our Certificate of Incorporation; where they differ, the law and the certificate prevail.

In one paragraph

Summary, in plain words — not a quote

Article II adopts the Fourth Law of Logic as the main framework for how CRIS thinks and decides. It states the Law, names the Principle of Continuous Fidelity and the Continuity Invariant, quoting each from its own document, and sets out five operators across six stages. Major decisions would come with a written Fourth Law Review. The Law guides the judgment of directors and officers, but it never displaces their legal duties.

The text

Article II — The Fourth Law of Logic

Section 2.1. Adoption. The Corporation adopts the Fourth Law of Logic, as formulated by its Founder and taught through the Academy of Philosophy-Engineering, as its main philosophical framework.

Section 2.2. Statement of the Law. The Fourth Law of Logic, as formulated by the Founder, states: A system remains valid and continues to exist only while its internal representations remain in verified correspondence with external reality; contradiction between the two is resolved not by discarding either, but by advancing to a state of greater continuity in which knowledge is preserved, corrected and accumulated.

Section 2.3. The Principle of Continuous Fidelity and the Continuity Invariant. The central institutional commitment drawn from the Fourth Law is the Principle of Continuous Fidelity, as stated in Article IV, Section 4.1 of the Founding Charter: Systems may change anything about themselves except their faithfulness to reality and their purpose. Its technical rule for intelligent systems is the Continuity Invariant, as stated in Article 3.2 of the CRIS AI Constitution: A CRIS System may change anything about itself except its correspondence with reality and its continuity of purpose. Where this Section and either source differ, the source governs.

Section 2.4. Operating Principles. The Fourth Law is applied through five operators, each carrying an operating principle, across six stages; the Continuity operator (C) carries two stages, Benefit and Continue:

OperatorStagePrincipleCommitment
EᵢObserveObservation (Learning)Observe reality with clarity and intellectual humility
↔VerifyCorrespondence (Verification)Verify through dialogue, evidence and rigorous reasoning
IᵢReasonReasoning (Computation)Reason, compute and engineer solutions
ΣAccumulateKnowledge (Accumulation)Accumulate and preserve knowledge for humanity
CBenefitContinuity (Benefit)Improve outcomes for people and the environment
CContinueContinuity (Continue)Remain the same system in purpose, and sustain the mission over time

Section 2.5. Application. The Board, its committees and the officers shall apply the Fourth Law when they:

  • set corporate strategy and research priorities;
  • exercise the public-benefit balancing required by DGCL §365 and Article VIII;
  • authorize, validate and deploy intelligent systems under Article IX;
  • design contributor compensation and participation under Article X; and
  • interpret any provision of these Bylaws whose meaning is unclear.

Section 2.6. Fourth Law Review. Any material decision on strategy, research direction, system deployment or contributor economics shall be accompanied by a written Fourth Law Review stating (a) the facts observed, (b) how claims were verified against evidence, (c) the reasoning applied, (d) what knowledge is preserved or created, and (e) the effect on the Corporation's continuity and public benefit. The Board may set the form and thresholds of this review by resolution.

Section 2.7. Fourth Law Council. The Board may establish a Fourth Law Council, chaired by the Founder while he is willing and able to serve, to advise on the meaning and application of the Fourth Law. The Council is advisory and has no corporate decision-making authority by virtue of that role.

Section 2.8. Relationship to Law and Fiduciary Duty. The Fourth Law guides how directors and officers exercise their judgment; it does not displace their fiduciary duties, the balancing duty under DGCL §365, the Certificate or any mandatory provision of law. Where they conflict, law and the Certificate prevail. Nothing in this Article creates a right of action for any person not otherwise provided by law.

Section 2.9. Publication. The Corporation shall maintain an authoritative text of the Fourth Law and the Principle of Continuous Fidelity among its corporate records and may publish it with its public-benefit reports.

Quoted exactly from the bylaws (version of 8 November 2026, approved by the Board for implementation on 20 November 2026). Headings, lists and tables are only laid out for reading.

In pictures

Five operators,
six stages
  1. Observe

    Observe the world as it is, and record where each observation came from.

    Learn more about observe →

  2. Verify

    Verify every observation, and every change a system makes to itself, against evidence it has not seen.

    Learn more about verify →

  3. Reason

    Reason only from what has been verified, in steps someone else can trace.

    Learn more about reason →

  4. Accumulate

    Accumulate what was verified, so knowledge adds up instead of being overwritten.

    Learn more about accumulate →

  5. Benefit

    Benefit people and the environment: participants share in the value they create, and every change is weighed against our public benefit purpose.

    Learn more about benefit →

  6. Continue

    Continue, changing anything except correspondence with reality and continuity of purpose.

    Learn more about continue →

  • EᵢObservationObserve
  • ↔CorrespondenceVerify
  • IᵢReasoningReason
  • ΣKnowledgeAccumulate
  • CContinuity (Benefit)Benefit
  • CContinuity (Continue)Continue
Section 2.4: five operators, each carrying an operating principle, across the six stages of the CRIS loop. The Continuity operator (C) carries two stages, Benefit and Continue. A summary, not a quotation.
  1. Decision proposedStrategy, research direction, deployment or contributor economics
  2. (a) Facts observedWhat is known, and how
  3. (b) VerifiedHow claims were checked against evidence
  4. (c) ReasoningThe reasoning applied
  5. (d) Knowledge keptWhat is preserved or created
  6. (e) Continuity effectOn continuity and public benefit
  7. Board decidesWith the written review in front of it
A Fourth Law Review under Section 2.6: five written answers before a material decision. A summary of the section; the Board may set the form and thresholds by resolution.

What it means in practice

For the Board, the Fourth Law becomes a habit of method. Before a material decision on strategy, research, deployment or contributor economics, the Board would expect a short written review. It covers what was observed, how it was checked, the reasoning, the knowledge kept and the effect on our public benefit.

For stockholders, nothing about their legal rights changes. Section 2.8 says the Law guides judgment and does not displace fiduciary duties, the balancing duty under Delaware law or the certificate. Where they conflict, the law and the certificate prevail.

For staff and researchers, the five operators and six stages describe how work is done: observe carefully, verify against evidence, reason openly, keep what is learned, benefit people and the environment, and stay true to purpose over time. The Fourth Law Council, if formed, advises on meaning; it decides nothing.

PrincipleIn a CRIS system
Observation (Eᵢ)Observation Mesh
Correspondence (↔)Correspondence Prover
Reasoning (Iᵢ)Reasoning and Redesign Core
Knowledge (Σ)Knowledge Ledger
Continuity, Benefit (C)The benefit scorecard
Continuity, Continue (C)C-Gate

How it connects

Awaiting counsel. Both drafting questions on this Article are settled: Section 2.3 quotes the Founding Charter and the AI Constitution by name, and Section 2.4 lists five operators across six stages. Counsel is reviewing the Article as a whole.

Next steps

Owner: Governance and ComplianceNext review: 2027-03-01