How rewards work
Participants are paid for the value their verified contributions create, under rules published before they apply.
In short
On CIX you are paid for the value your verified contributions create, under rules published before they apply. A share of what CRIS earns from them goes to contributors first, before CRIS takes its fee. Nothing on this page is adopted yet, and no amount, rate or date is promised.
Proposed. The Contributor Rights Charter, the reward rules and the Published Method are proposed; nothing on this page is adopted, and no amount, rate or date is promised. CIX: Status to be confirmed Participation Value Meter: Status to be confirmed Registering interest is the only step open today.
During the pilot. How pilot contributions are paid before any product earns revenue is still to be decided (Q1), and will be stated here, and on every pilot task, before anyone contributes.
Not an investment. Contributing does not make you a shareholder in CRIS or give you a vote. Payments are for the licence you grant and the work you do. You never pay to take part. Counsel is confirming, country by country, that no payment is treated as an investment (Article 15.2).
The path, from consent to payout
The page follows one contribution from the moment you agree to share it to the moment you see the payment on your Value Statement.
- Consent, tier. You choose what to share and how it may be used, before you start.
- Contribution. You contribute an observation, data, a judgement, an evaluation, a correction, code, teaching material or a review.
- Verification. It is checked against other evidence; if it fails, it comes back with the reason.
- Value Points. It earns points by a method chosen for its kind, published before it applies.
- Used in a product. It is used, or it is not; a verified item that is never used still earns a minimum.
- Pool, before fee. A share of revenue goes into a pool for contributors before CRIS takes its fee.
- Payout. You are paid your share of the pool, through a licensed payment partner.
- Value Statement. You see how in a Value Statement, line by line, with a way to question each line.
Step 1: consent and the licence tier
Before you contribute, you are told in plain words, in a language you understand, what will be collected and why, which CRIS systems or research results may use it and who will see it, the licence tiers the task accepts, and how it will be valued and paid (Article 4.1). Consent is given actively, recorded in CIX, and asked again before any new use.
You keep your rights in what you contribute. You grant CRIS only the licence the task needs, at the tier you chose; nothing transfers ownership unless you sign a separate written assignment (Article 4.2). You choose one of four tiers. Only the Commercial tier earns royalties.
| Tier 1 Open | Tier 2 Research | Tier 3 Commercial | Tier 4 Restricted | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CRIS publishes openly | Yes, credited | No | No | If agreed |
| CRIS licenses to buyers | As open data | No | Yes | If agreed |
| You receive | Value Points | Value Points | Value Points and royalties | As agreed; at least Tier 2 |
| If you withdraw | CRIS stops; open copies stay | Future use stops | CRIS stops; sold copies keep their licence | As agreed |
From Schedule B of the proposed Charter. Tier 3 is the only tier that earns royalties. You may move a contribution to a more open tier at any time; a more restrictive tier applies to future use (Art. 12.3).
Knowledge held by a community is used only with the community's free, prior and informed consent, given through its own decision-making process, and under a written benefit-sharing agreement at Tier 4 (Article 13).
Steps 2 to 5: verification and Value Points
Only verified contributions earn points. A contribution is checked against other evidence; if it fails, it comes back with the reason and can be corrected and resubmitted. A track record may weigh in, but is never the only reason for rejection (Article 8). How points are worked out depends on what you contribute: each verified observation or data item earns points; evaluations share equally; corrections earn by how much they improve a system; large studies share credit.
| Kind of contribution | Usual method (Art. 7.2) |
|---|---|
| Observation | Points per item |
| Data | Points per item |
| Expert judgement | Equal shares, weighted by expertise |
| Annotation and evaluation | Equal shares |
| Correction | Measured improvement |
| Code and tools | Measured improvement or shared credit |
| Research and teaching | Shared credit |
| Review and verification | Paid as a task |
From Schedule A. A verified contribution that is never used still earns the minimum for its kind (Art. 6.3); the minimums are in brackets until set.
Within each method, a verified contribution’s points are V = G × B × (0.40 Q + 0.30 R + 0.30 U): verified (G), the base points for the method (B), quality (Q), rarity (R) and measured use (U). The weights are proposed for adoption (Art. 7.3). The Value Meter page explains each letter.
The same contribution earns the same points wherever you live (Article 19.1), and no contribution is valued lower because it was made in a language other than English or over a low-bandwidth channel (Article 9.2). Duplicate accounts, collusion, automated submissions and copies may be discounted under published rules.
The Value Meter's method and its fairness checks will be published before they apply, so anyone can see how a reward was worked out.
- ContributionVerified, in the ledger
- Measured effectThe improvement it caused
- AttributionShared across contributors
- Published rulesMethod and fairness checks, published before use
- PayoutThrough a licensed payment partner
Step 6: the pool, paid first
For every product built from contributions, a share of its revenue goes into the Contributor Value Pool before CRIS takes its fee (Article 16). Each year the Board may direct a further share of surplus to contributors. The pool is held separately, used only to pay contributors, and reported every year. Research and industry buyers of verified knowledge pay exchange fees; grants and partners fund pilots.
Steps 7 and 8: payment and the Value Statement
You are paid your share of the pool, in local currency, through a licensed payment partner, including by mobile money where practicable. Balances below the minimum payout carry forward; nothing is forfeited. Every payment comes with a Value Statement showing each verified contribution, its points and the rule applied, the products that used it, royalties earned and payments made, with a way to question any line. Totals and their distribution by country and group will be published with our public-benefit statement.
| Rule | Proposed text | Value today |
|---|---|---|
| Partner | A licensed payment partner, named publicly before payouts begin | [to be named] |
| Means | Local currency and the means people use, including mobile money where practicable; CRIS bears transfer fees where practicable | — |
| Minimum payout | Balances below it carry forward and are never forfeited | [__] in local currency |
| Schedule | At least | [quarterly] |
| Tax | Contributors are responsible for their own taxes; CRIS issues statements and withholds only where the law requires, saying so on the statement | — |
Article 18 of the proposed Charter. Values print as numbers only once set; until then they keep the Charter’s brackets.
Rewards may be taxable where you live. Your Value Statement will help, but we cannot give tax advice.
Four ways to be paid
Each task says, before it starts, which of these apply (Article 15.1).
- Task payments. A task may pay for your time or effort, as it says before you start, at least the living-income benchmark (Art. 6.2, Art. 19.2).
- Value payouts. Your points earn a share of the pool (Art. 16.4).
- Royalties. Tier 3 contributions earn royalties while they stay in commercial use (Art. 17).
- Programme support. Support such as scholarships and grants, where a programme offers it (Art. 15.1).
Royalties
Royalties are the one payment that continues after a contribution is first used, and only at Tier 3.
- When: for Tier 3 contributions, for as long as CRIS, or a licensee of CRIS, uses them commercially.
- How much: each period, a royalty pool of [__]% of the product’s net revenue, shared among its Tier 3 contributors by points, by the same formula as the value payout.
- How long: the commercial life of the product, and at least [five] years from the contribution, unless it is removed.
- Following the licence: a buyer who licenses a dataset or model built with Tier 3 contributions must report use, so royalties keep reaching contributors (Art. 17.3).
If you leave
You can withdraw at any time. New use stops at once, and the points and royalties you have already earned are kept.
| When you withdraw | What happens |
|---|---|
| New use | Stops at once; collection from you stops |
| Datasets not yet delivered | Your contribution is removed |
| Systems that used it | It is left out of the next scheduled training or update |
| The ledger | Your verified contribution stays as part of the permanent record, without your identity |
| Points and royalties already earned | Kept. Royalties continue while the contribution stays in commercial use, and stop when it is removed |
| Confirmation | In writing: what was done, and when |
Article 14 of the proposed Charter. A model already trained with a contribution cannot always forget it at once, and datasets already licensed continue under their licence (Art. 14.2); see the FAQ.
A worked example
The proposed Charter shows the arithmetic with invented numbers in its Schedule C. Here is the same example, without a currency.
- One item’s points. A verified crop-price observation: base 10; quality 1.2, rarity 1.0, use 0.9. Points = 10 × (0.40 × 1.2 + 0.30 × 1.0 + 0.30 × 0.9) = 10.5.
- Sharing a sale. A buyer pays 10,000 for the dataset. With an invented floor of 60%, 6,000 goes into the pool before CRIS takes its fee. Three contributors earned 300, 150, 50 points (500 in all), so they receive 3,600, 1,800, 600.
- Royalties. The dataset was licensed at Tier 3. Next year it earns 20,000 of net revenue. At an invented royalty rate of 10%, the 2,000 royalty pool is shared the same way: 1,200, 600, 200.
Source: Schedule C of the proposed Contributor Rights Charter, with no currency shown. The figures are computed when the site is built and checked against the Charter. The Value Meter page shows the same sale as shares of the pool.
Compute Thermodynamic Units (CTU)
Metered CTU measure the energy and compute cost of each improvement. They let the Value Meter weigh what an improvement achieved against what it cost, so that rewards follow real progress rather than raw activity. The published method will explain exactly how CTU enter the calculation. CTU are not yet used in any reward calculation. See what CTU is, and is not, and metered CTU.
Fairness, appeal and a voice on the rules
Every payout run would be checked for fairness. The proposed Contributor Rights Charter, Article 9.1, says it “shall be checked for fairness by country, gender, language, disability, experience and over time”, and any failure is corrected and reported. A payout run is never changed afterwards; errors are corrected by a new, linked entry, and each year an independent reviewer samples payout runs and re-runs their calculations. The Participation Value Meter page explains the method, the rules and the checks in full.
If you disagree with any decision about your contributions or payments:
| Step | Who decides | Time limit (proposed) | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Ask | The team that decided | [10] days | A written explanation |
| 2 Review | A different team | [30] days | A written decision |
| 3 Appeal | The Audit Council or, until it is appointed, an independent reviewer | [45] days | A decision that binds CRIS, not you |
| 4 The law | A mediator or court | As the law provides | Any legal remedy |
Article 23 and Schedule E. Appeals are free, and nobody is penalised for appealing. If an appeal succeeds, CRIS corrects the points and pays any shortfall with interest at [__]% a year in the next payout (Art. 23.4). Anyone affected by an automated decision can have a person review it (Art. 4.10).
Under the proposed Charter, the rules sit in layers: the Board sets the principles, then the Published Method, then the reward rules, then each payout run. Each layer changes only through the layer above it. The method changes only after public notice, and every version stays published with the dates it applied. Once formed, an elected Contributors' Council is consulted before any change to the method, the reward rules, the tiers or the Charter, and publishes its own opinion (Article 20).
Still to be decided
The values the reward rules will set are listed in Schedule D of the proposed Contributor Rights Charter.
| Rule | Charter | Value | Set by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contributor Value Pool floor | Art. 16.1 | [__]% | Board, on the Contributors' Council's advice |
| Royalty rate | Art. 17.2 | [__]% | Board |
| Minimum royalty duration | Art. 17.4 | [five] years | Board |
| Minimum payout | Art. 18.3 | [__] in local currency | Reward rules |
| Payment schedule | Art. 18.3 | [quarterly] | Reward rules |
| Living-income benchmark source | Art. 19.2 | [source to be chosen] | Reward rules |
| Unclaimed balances kept for | Art. 16.3 | [three] years | Board |
| Interest on a shortfall | Art. 23.4 | [__]% a year | Board |
| Payment partner | Art. 18.1 | [to be named] | CEO and counsel |
From Schedule D of the proposed Charter, read from data. A value prints as a number only once it is set; the table shrinks as values are decided.
Two questions sit outside it:
| Decision | Owner |
|---|---|
| How pilot contributions are paid before any product earns revenue (Q1) | CIX Product Lead, with counsel |
| Whether SCVX social-capital rewards are offered in the pilot (Q2) | [to be decided: see Q2] |
SCVX. An organisation also led by our Founder; any work with CRIS is under a separate written agreement. Related organisations Because our chief executive also leads SCVX, the workflow proposes that this decision is taken by people without that interest: Board, on Governance's advice.
What this page will never say
A page about money is read as a promise unless it is written not to be.
| We never write | Because | We write instead |
|---|---|---|
| Reads as a promise | paid for the value your verified contributions create | |
| Reads as a security | payments for the licence you grant and the work you do | |
| Nothing is guaranteed before adoption | the proposed rules say… | |
| Royalties last for the commercial life of a product, with a proposed minimum | royalties while the contribution stays in commercial use | |
| Not in the proposed Charter | leave out unless counsel approves |
| Limit | What it means |
|---|---|
| Nothing is adopted | The Charter, the reward rules and the method are proposals; counsel, the CIX Product Lead and the Public Benefit Officer must approve them first |
| No values are set | Every Schedule D value stays in brackets until set, with who sets it |
| CIX is not open | Registering interest is the only step open today; the invited pilot is planned for phase 2, and only once the participant terms are approved |
| Pilot payouts | Still to be decided (Q1); stated before anyone contributes |
| Not an investment | Contributing does not make anyone a stockholder or give voting rights; counsel is confirming, country by country, that no payment is treated as an investment |
| Tax | Rewards may be taxable where you live; CRIS cannot give tax advice |
| Countries | Only where CIX can pay lawfully; no country is named as a pilot location until agreed in writing and approved for publication |
Who reads it
| Reader | Must find on this page | Linked out to |
|---|---|---|
| Would-be contributor | What they can be paid, in what forms, when, and what they keep; that nothing is promised | FAQ; Join CIX |
| Expert | That judgement is valued by equal shares weighted by expertise, and that equal value earns equal points everywhere | Value Meter: attribution |
| Community leader | That community knowledge needs the community’s own consent and a written benefit-sharing agreement at Tier 4 | Charter Art. 13 |
| Regulator or journalist | That no amount is promised; that contributing is not an investment; that the rules are proposals | Charter Art. 15.2 |
| Buyer of data | That Tier 3 data carries royalties and a duty to report use | Charter Art. 17 |
| Council member or auditor | Where the method log and payout runs will be published, and how to re-run one | Value Meter: settlement; benefit report |
The road
| Date (proposed) | Step | Today |
|---|---|---|
| 12 Nov 2026 | This review | Done |
| 27 Nov 2026 | Quick fixes: tense; not an investment; tax and withdrawal lines; status line; the SCVX row | Done on this preview |
| 18 Dec 2026 | Page rebuilt on the eight steps | Done on this preview |
| 15 Jan 2027 | Pilot payouts (Q1) and the SCVX question (Q2) decided and written into the page | Open |
| 26 Feb 2027 | Reward rules and Published Method version 1 put forward for approval; Schedule D values set or kept in brackets; payment partner named if agreed | Open |
| 1 Mar 2027 | Page review date | — |
| Mar–Apr 2027 | Phase 2 invited pilot (proposed), only once the participant terms are approved | — |
If the rules are not approved by the time the pilot is ready, the pilot waits. The page never runs ahead of the rules.
About this page
| Anchor | Section | Old anchor kept |
|---|---|---|
#in-short | The idea, what is and is not promised, status | #in-one-paragraph |
#consent | Step 1: consent and the licence tier | — |
#points | Steps 2–5: contribution, verification, Value Points | #how-value-flows |
#pool | Step 6: the pool, paid first | #who-pays |
#payout | Steps 7–8: payment and the Value Statement | #payments |
#four-ways | The four forms of payment | — |
#royalties | Royalties, Tier 3 | — |
#leaving | What withdrawal does to payments | — |
#example | Illustrative worked example | — |
#ctu | CTU: what they will do; not yet used | unchanged |
#appeal | Fairness, appeal, layers of rules, the Council | #fairness-and-appeal |
#still-to-be-decided | Schedule D values, Q1, the SCVX row | unchanged |
| Check | Fails when |
|---|---|
rw-promise | A word on the avoid list appears on a CIX page, outside a sentence that rules it out |
rw-tense | The method, rules or CIX are said to be published or paying while no method version is published |
rw-brackets | A Schedule D value prints as a number while it is not set |
rw-example | Example values print outside the example block, or the computed results differ from Schedule C |
rw-banner | The example renders without its illustrative banner above it |
rw-status | The status line is typed rather than read from status data |
rw-proposed | The Charter, reward rules or method appear without “proposed” while the Charter is not adopted |
rw-related | SCVX, BGTI, LOGOS-C or the Academy is named without the related-party line |
rw-partner | A payment partner or pilot country is named without a recorded agreement and approval |
rw-anchors | #ctu or any old anchor disappears |
All ten run in every build.
What changed
| # | Finding | Fixed by |
|---|---|---|
| K1 | Said the method and fairness checks are published; they are not yet | “Will be published before they apply”, here, in the FAQ and in the value-flow figure |
| K2 | No licence tiers, four forms of payment or royalties | Consent and tiers; four ways; royalties |
| K3 | One valuation method shown; the Charter has four | Eight kinds, four methods; the minimum for unused items |
| K4 | Nothing on how pilot contributions are paid | A pilot line, open until Q1 is decided |
| K5 | Formula and worked example absent | The formula in one line; the example, computed and labelled |
| K6 | The page and the rules must land together | The road; values from data |
| K7 | Appeal route without its steps and times | The four steps, times in brackets, interest, a person for automated decisions |
| K8 | SCVX row without the related-party line; owner with an interest | Line added; owner to be decided (Q2) |
| K9 | Not-an-investment and tax lines missing | Both added |
| K10 | What withdrawal does to payments | Earned points and royalties kept |
| K11 | Rules in layers and the Contributors’ Council missing | Both added |
| K12 | No status line | CIX and Value Meter status read from data |
