Participation Value Meter
Fair, published rules for what a contribution is worth.
In one paragraph
The Participation Value Meter turns verified human contribution into fair pay. When contributions on the Continuity Intelligence Exchange improve a CRIS system or a research result, the Value Meter measures that improvement, shares it among the people who caused it under a method we publish, and pays them through a licensed payment partner, before CRIS takes its fee. It then publishes the totals, so anyone can see where the value went.
Its label, Σ → value, means accumulated, verified knowledge turned into economic value. It is how we carry out the part of our charter that names "platforms converting human participation into measurable economic value". For the participant's view of the same rules, see How rewards work.
Where it sits
The Value Meter carries the Benefit stage of the loop. It answers one question for every verified contribution: how much is this worth, and to whom? In Workflow B, a contribution reaches the Value Meter only after the Correspondence Prover has verified it and the Knowledge Ledger has recorded it. The Value Meter scores it at step 6 and rewards it at step 7.
Rules for this system are proposed in the Contributor Rights Charter, Part III and Articles 16–18.
A more continuous tomorrow.
Observe
Observe the world as it is, and record where each observation came from.
Verify
Verify every observation, and every change a system makes to itself, against evidence it has not seen.
Reason
Reason only from what has been verified, in steps someone else can trace.
Accumulate
Accumulate what was verified, so knowledge adds up instead of being overwritten.
Benefit
Benefit people and the environment: participants share in the value they create, and every change is weighed against our public benefit purpose.
Continue
Continue, changing anything except correspondence with reality and continuity of purpose.
- 1Join CIXVia the web or the CES app
- 2Consent and IDPrivacy and ownership
- 3ContributeAn observation or insight
- 4Verified?Correspondence Prover · ↔No → feedback, try again
- 5Enter ledgerKnowledge Ledger · Σ
- 6Value MeterScores the contribution
- 7RewardPaid; reputation rises
- 8Benefit reportAggregate and public
What it reads
Every input comes from a verified record, and every output can be traced back to one.
- Knowledge LedgerVerified contributions, with provenance and consent
- Buyer ordersWhat was bought, and for how much
- Improvement measuresHow much a system or result improved
- Published rulesThe method, floor and fees in force
- Contribution scoresPer item and per person
- Payout fileTo the licensed payment partner
- StatementsFor each participant
- Aggregate figuresFor the public benefit report
| Input | Source | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Verified contributions | Knowledge Ledger | Only verified items earn value |
| Buyer orders | CIX settlement | The money that is shared |
| Improvement measures | Correspondence Prover; buyers' results | How much difference a contribution made |
| Published rules | The method and reward rules in force | The basis for every calculation |
How it works
Every payout follows the same four steps.
- 1AttributeMeasured improvement, to the contributions that caused it
- 2ApplyPublished reward rules and fairness checks
- 3SettlePayments through a licensed payment partner
- 4PublishAggregate statistics on contributions and payouts
- Attribute measured improvement to the contributions that caused it.
- Apply the published reward rules and fairness checks across regions and groups.
- Settle payments through a licensed payment partner.
- Publish aggregate statistics on contributions and how payouts were distributed.
The trigger is a verified contribution entering the Knowledge Ledger. The output is contribution scores and payouts.
How value is attributed
The hardest question the Value Meter answers is who caused an improvement, and by how much. Different kinds of contribution create value in different ways, so the Value Meter uses methods suited to each: points for verified items in a dataset, equal shares for evaluations, and measured improvement for corrections to a model. Every method will be published in plain words and tested before it is used.
- Per verified item, weightedPoints per verified item, weighted by rarity and qualityGood forDatasets bought as a whole; simple to explainLimitRough for model improvements
- Marginal contributionHow much the result changes with and without a contributionGood forModel corrections and evaluationsLimitNeeds repeated tests
- Shared creditAverages each contribution’s effect across many combinationsGood forFair sharing across many contributorsLimitCostly to compute; approximations needed
| Product | Likely method | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Verified datasets | Points per verified item, weighted by rarity and quality | The buyer pays for the whole set; each item's share is clear |
| Evaluation panels | Equal shares per completed, verified evaluation, weighted by expertise | Each evaluation is a comparable unit of work |
| Model corrections | How much the model improves with each correction | The value lies in the improvement, not the count |
| Large pooled studies | Shared-credit methods, approximated | Fair sharing across many contributors |
Continuity Labs chooses the methods, tests them on historical or synthetic data, and publishes them before the pilot opens.
A worked example
Here is how one order could be shared, using the points of the worked example in Schedule C of the proposed Contributor Rights Charter. A buyer pays for a verified crop-price dataset. At least the published floor goes to the participants who built it, and CRIS keeps the rest for verification, the platform, support and audit. Each participant's share of the pool depends only on the value points their verified items earned. The example is an illustration: the floor, fees and amounts will be set by the approved reward rules.
- Participant A300 points · Many verified items of good valuethree fifths of the pool
- Participant B150 points · Fewer items, or items of less valuethree tenths
- Participant C50 points · A few itemsone tenth
Three contributors earned 500 points in total. Participant A’s share of the pool is 300 ÷ 500, three fifths.
Rules and fairness
Our board sets the principles: participants are paid first, there is a published minimum share for participants, and pay must be fair across countries, genders and languages. Below the principles sit the published method, the reward rules and each payout run, and each layer can change only through the one above it.
- 1Board principlesParticipants paid first; a published floor; fairness; publicationBoard, consulting the Public Benefit Office
- 2Published methodHow value is attributed and checkedContinuity Labs; counsel; Public Benefit Office
- 3Reward rulesFloor, fees, minimum payout, scheduleParticipation Platforms; counsel
- 4Each payout runCalculations under the rules in forceChecked by fairness checks and an audit sample
| Layer | Contains | Approved by | Changed by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Board principles | Participants paid first; a published floor; fairness; publication | Board, consulting the Public Benefit Office | Board resolution |
| Published method | Attribution and checks | Continuity Labs; counsel; Public Benefit Office | Public notice before any change |
| Reward rules | Floor, fees, minimum payout, schedule | Participation Platforms; counsel | Public notice; Contributors' Council (proposed) consulted |
| Each payout run | Calculations under the rules in force | Fairness checks; audit sample | Never changed afterwards; only corrected by a new entry |
Every payout run is checked against those principles. Our risk register names the danger these checks guard against: human contributors manipulated or underpaid (book Chapters 12.4–12.5 and 14.5). Any failure is corrected and reported.
- By countryPaid in line with the value created
- By genderSimilar records, similar pay
- By languageLess common languages valued fairly
- By disabilityNo one valued lower for a disability
- By tierNewcomers can progress
- Over timeStable, explained payouts
Buyers pay; participants are paid first; CRIS takes its fee at a published rate; and the totals are reported.
Continuity Research & Intelligent Systems, P.B.C. (CRIS) is responsible for the personal data described here, except where a service’s own notice names someone else. [Registered address to be added.] Privacy questions and requests: governance@criscontinuity.tech [a dedicated privacy@ address once set up]. Until a privacy lead is named, the Governance and Compliance team answers privacy questions.
Settlement and publication
Payments are made through a licensed payment partner, in local currency and through mobile money where available. Each participant receives a statement showing how their payout was worked out.
- Payout runRegular, on the schedule set in the reward rules
- Minimum payoutSmaller balances carried forward
- Licensed payment partnerLocal currency and mobile money
- ParticipantPaid; statement updated
| Question | Proposal |
|---|---|
| Who pays out? | A licensed payment partner, chosen before the pilot |
| In what form? | Local currency, including mobile money where available |
| How often? | A regular payout run, set in the reward rules |
| Minimum payout | Set with the payment partner; smaller balances carried forward |
| Statements | Each participant sees items, points, the rules applied and payments |
| Social capital or tokens | Not part of the pilot; only with their own regulatory approval |
Every year we publish the total value paid to participants, the share it represents, how it was distributed, and how long payments took, all in aggregate so that no individual can be identified. Two of these, the total paid and its distribution, are people indicators in our public benefit scorecard.
- Total value paidTo participants, by year
- Share paid to participantsAgainst the published floor
- DistributionBy country, gender and language
- Time to payoutAverage and slowest tenth
- Fairness resultsThe fairness checks and any corrections
- AppealsRaised, resolved and time taken
Explanation and appeal
If you think a payout is wrong, you can ask how it was calculated and appeal. Every appeal ends with someone outside the team that made the decision. Two of the six commitments in our participant charter fall to the Value Meter: fair value (the reward rules and the Value Meter method are public) and redress.
- StatementItems, points and the rules applied
- QuestionRaised in the app
- ReviewBy the CIX team, with reasons
- AppealTo someone outside the team that decided
Status and read more
This status is set by the CRIS team and links to the evidence behind it. The Value Meter makes its first real payouts only in the CIX pilot.
Current status: Status to be confirmed
| Level | Evidence required | Who sets it |
|---|---|---|
| Research | Concept page; draft method and reward principles published | CEO |
| Prototype | Method tested on historical or synthetic data; test payouts calculated | CEO, on the Labs and Systems leads’ advice |
| Pilot | Real payouts in the CIX pilot through a licensed partner; fairness checks run; appeals handled | CEO |
| Live | Production use; external audit of payouts; figures in the benefit report | CEO, with notice to the board |
For developers: Concepts: the loop as data (the value record format is planned).
- How rewards work: the participant's view of the same rules.
- The Continuity Intelligence Exchange and the participant charter.
- Recursion Without Rupture: Chapters 12.4–12.5 (participants' rights) and Chapter 14 (the participation economy).
- Related systems: CIX, Knowledge Ledger, Correspondence Prover, Continuity Audit Suite.
